Multifamily cap rates and why they matter relative to loan rates

A capitalization rate (cap rate) is one of the most important metrics in multifamily real estate. It measures the annual return a property generates from its operating income relative to its purchase price, before mortgage payments, that is assuming you paid cash.
The relationship between the cap rate and your loan interest rate is particularly important because it helps determine whether borrowing money to buy an apartment building creates value or puts pressure on your cash flow.
1. What is a cap rate?
The formula is:
CapRate=NetOperatingIncome(NOI)PropertyValue100
Net operating income (NOI) is rental and other operating income minus operating expenses, such as property management, payroll, insurance, maintenance, and property taxes. NOI is calculated before mortgage payments, income taxes, depreciation, and capital expenditures.
Here's a simple example.
Example: 100-unit apartment building
Purchase price
$20,000,000
Annual NOI
$1,200,000
Cap rate
6.0%
Calculation: $1,200,000 ÷ $20,000,000 = 6.0%
This property generates $1.2 million in annual NOI on a $20 million purchase price, giving it a 6% cap rate.
Importantly, the 6% is an unleveraged property yield, not your actual return on equity. Your equity return clearly depends on financing, capital expenditures, and other factors.
2. Why the cap rate matters relative to your loan interest rate
The key concept is the spread between the property's cap rate and the cost of debt.
Cap rate above the loan rate: Potentially favorable financing economics, because the property's initial NOI yield exceeds the interest rate, known as positive equity.
Cap rate equal to the loan rate: Little or no initial yield advantage from leverage before amortization and other costs, flat equity.
Cap rate below the loan rate: Negative initial spread; debt may reduce returns relative to an all-cash purchase, although appreciation and future NOI growth could still make the investment worthwhile, known as negative equity.
For example, consider a property with a 6% cap rate and a $12 million loan at 7% interest. The property generates income at a lower rate than the interest cost on the borrowed capital. This is commonly called negative leverage, negative equity.
One important qualification: cap rate is calculated using NOI divided by the entire property value, while the loan rate applies only to the borrowed amount. The spread is a useful first screening tool, but it is not a complete measure of profitability.
3. A $20 million multifamily deal: how the numbers work
Let's apply this to a hypothetical acquisition.
Assume the property has $1.2 million in NOI and you borrow $12 million, or 60% of the purchase price.
Illustrative financing scenarios — interest-only debt
Metric
Scenario A
Scenario B
Purchase price
$20M
$20M
Annual NOI
$1.2M
$1.2M
Cap rate
6.0%
6.0%
Loan amount
$12M
$12M
Interest rate
5.0%
7.0%
Annual interest
$600K
$840K
Cash flow before other costs
$600K
$360K
Cash-on-cash return*
7.5%
4.5%
*Assumes $8M of equity and excludes closing costs, capital expenditures, reserves, and other ownership costs. Both scenarios use interest-only loans to isolate the interest-rate effect.
Notice what happens: the property and its NOI haven't changed, but raising the interest rate from 5% to 7% reduces annual cash flow by $240,000.
That's why financing terms matter so much. A building can be operationally profitable while producing a disappointing return for equity investors.
4. How cap rates affect property values
Cap rates also help determine what a property is worth.
If your apartment building produces $1.2 million in annual NOI:
Property value at different cap rates
Illustrative values for the same $1.2 million annual NOI.
The relationship is inverse: when cap rates rise, property values fall, assuming NOI remains unchanged.
For example, at a 5% cap rate, $1.2 million in NOI supports a $24 million valuation. At a 6% cap rate, the same income supports a $20 million valuation.
This is one reason rising interest rates can put pressure on apartment values. Buyers need a better income yield to justify the price when financing becomes more expensive.
5. What I would focus on when underwriting a multifamily acquisition
For your multifamily acquisition, I would evaluate these five metrics together:
Going-in cap rate: NOI divided by the actual purchase price.
Loan constant: Annual principal and interest payments divided by the loan amount.
Debt service coverage ratio (DSCR): NOI divided by annual debt service. This measures the property's ability to cover its loan payments.
Cash-on-cash return: Annual pre-tax cash flow after debt service divided by the equity invested.
Exit cap rate: The cap rate assumed when selling the property, which can materially affect projected sale proceeds and investor returns.
The goal isn't necessarily to find a property whose cap rate exceeds its interest rate by a particular amount. It's to find a property whose income, financing terms, and purchase price support attractive returns without creating excessive cash-flow risk.





Comments